elwinfortuna: (one ring you know you want it)
Elwin ([personal profile] elwinfortuna) wrote2019-08-17 11:07 am

Dear Innumerable Stars Writer/Artist:

I'm [archiveofourown.org profile] amyfortuna aka [tumblr.com profile] edgeoflight.

I'm so excited that you'll be writing /drawing for me! I can't wait to see what you come up with.

What I generally love to see in fanworks:
  • Loyalty and genuine devotion.
  • Meaningful sacrifice.
  • When repressed emotion comes out, especially if it's about love that the character thinks is unrequited but turns out to be requited.
  • A strong sense of love and caring.
  • Hope in the midst of despair.
  • Endearments and affection.
  • Desperate need or longing for love (that is then provided).
  • Rescues from the brink of death.
  • Eucatastrophe (the opposite of catastrophe - a sudden joyous turn in a story).
  • Quarrels and fights, high emotional stakes and risks, passion raging out of control, desperation, and sudden impulses.
  • Canon-divergence! (Especially Fëanorians Win AUs.)
  • Meeting someone for the first time and feeling an instant kinship with them.
  • Loyalty or devotion to a cause or a person.
  • Working together like a well-oiled machine.
  • Battlefield friendships.
  • Enemies working together to defeat a common greater enemy (then figuring out that they aren't really enemies anymore).
  • Admiring someone's skill or competence.
  • Compassion, mercy, and pity as themes.
  • Geopolitics, maps, layouts of houses and lands.
  • Art or fic inspired by my own fic: remixes, fanart, based on, using the same plotline, etc.


For art: Visual depictions of any of the prompts would be really good - I've tried to give prompts that can be depicted as art in some way. But mainly I'm interested to see your vision of the setting and the characters. I am utterly indifferent to conventional beauty standards and would in fact prefer to see age lines where appropriate, as well as people of varying sizes, shapes, and skin tones.

I absolutely adore maps and architecture; I draw clumsy layouts of houses and lands when I need to visualise where in a space people might be, and I would love anything you can come up with -- a layout of Himring, a map of Rivendell, architectural plans for Bag End, etc, etc.

I'm especially interested in art as character study: what a character wears, carries, is using, is doing, says so much about who they are as a person.

If you'd like to draw me smuttier art, I love suggestive clothing just as much as full nakedness and am always on board for one partner being fully clothed while the other one is naked. I love rumpled garments, clothing half off, blissful expressions on faces, arms around each other, hard nipples on men and women, erections for men, women who are visibly wet. I adore hair - long hair on heads, underarm hair, beards where relevant, women with muff. I would be in the seventh heaven to receive art depicting any scene from my own fic.

Regarding romance/sex:
I love kink and smut! I'm cool with any kind of ship: poly relationships, het, femslash, and slash, as well as of course solo masturbation and sex that doesn't really fall into the above categories at all. I'm cool with underage as long as all parties have been through puberty, and I adore teacher/student dynamics or situations where the parties involved have unequal levels of power (especially if it's Complicated). Loyalty kink is my FAVE, and I like it to be mutual.

For BDSM specifically, I prefer mind or power games to whips and chains, or alternatively, playful experimentation rather than Serious BDSM Is Serious. Dubious consent can also be fun to play with, especially somnophilia or scenarios that involve sex pollen or being forced to have sex by a third party. I love seeing characters so mutually overwhelmed by desire that they can't resist each other. I have no real boundaries when it comes to kink or sex acts (other than my DNWs) and will happily read anything, though I particularly enjoy:

For ships involving only men: auto-anal and auto-fellatio, rimming, watersports, comeplay of all kinds, nipple sucking (especially ritualised), intercrural sex, frottage (especially clothed frottage including coming in pants), and lovingly described blowjobs. Anal sex is good too, but I prefer it not be considered the be-all and end-all of sex between men.

For ships involving only women: cunnilingus, any kind of anal play, especially rimming, strap-on play, nipple play, and tribadism.

For ships involving a man and a woman: Cunnilingus, vaginal sex, anal sex. I like it when the pair are either both equally in control or the woman is but that doesn't necessarily mean she has to be on top. (Not a fan of het fic where the man is totally in control and the woman is virginal and sort of swept away by him.)

For threesomes/moresomes involving men and women: femdom, pegging, cunnilingus, especially queening, vaginal sex, and submissive men getting tied up.


And then, there are some things I don't love and would rather not see in fic:
  • Outright rape/noncon, torture, or extreme physical or mental suffering.

  • A focus on sickness or illness, or pregnancy and babies (except where specifically requested). Ok to mention these things as they are part of life, but I don't want a fic all about them.

  • Extreme, out-of-character, romantic angst or miscommunication. If the problem keeping the lovers apart can be solved with one straightforward conversation, then it's gone too far. Legitimate misunderstanding or miscommunication is entirely fine.

  • For smut: scat, vomiting, heavy BDSM like ritualised whipping or beating.

  • Homophobia, biphobia, transphobia, racism, sexism or the effects thereof as a major part of the story.

  • Character-bashing. Don't do it to any character, but especially not to the Fëanorians. I love them and want them to be happy.

  • Redemption, sorrow for "sin," angsting forever by the seaside, the Valar being right and good in everything they do, and characters needing to suffer for the things they've done.


I haven't had time to add prompts for everything yet, I'll be adding these in over the next couple of days. Prompts are optional; if you get another idea, just run with it!

Worldbuilding tags are concepts I'm interested in, if you can fit them in, great, but if not, don't worry about it.

Onward to the fandoms!

The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-earth: gen and single character requests

Group: Míriel & Daurin | Tórin, Míriel Þerindë | Míriel Serindë, Daurin | Tórin
Míriel and Daurin, together and separately, are a couple of very intriguing characters for me. We know that Daurin was Fëanor's kinsman and it's a pretty firm headcanon of mine that it was Míriel he was related to rather than Finwë. So what was he to Míriel? Brother, uncle, cousin? Why did he come to Valinor? What was their life like at Cuiviénen? I'd also love to hear about Míriel's personality and talents -- I choose the 'Character Study' tag with her in mind. I have a sort of half-formed headcanon that she came to Valinor because it allowed her greater possibilities for her work. She strikes me as someone who was very driven and focused, very passionate about the works of her hands (and Fëanor gets that from her), in an entirely positive sense.

Group: Gil-galad & Tar-Aldarion, Group: Tar-Meneldur & Gil-galad
I'm particularly interested in Gil-galad's letter to Tar-Meneldur and what that reveals about both his personality and his attitude toward his role as High King of the Noldor in the Second Age. I've got several worldbuilding tags with these two relationships in mind. (I've used he/his for Gil-galad but I am 110% up for Finduilas-as-Gil-galad scenarios as well.)

Group: Nienna & Olórin
Gandalf is one of my favourite characters of all-time, and I want to hear about his "youth" in Aman. I sort of get the impression that he served quite a few of the Valar, searching for a purpose, maybe? His relationship with Nienna especially intrigues me -- how did she teach him pity and patience? Impatient, somewhat pitiless Olórin would be exciting to see!

Group: Finrod & Bëor
I would love to hear about Bëor's life in Nargothrond. How did he serve Finrod? Did he keep in touch with his own people? What did the other elves think of him, the first mortal they would presumably have met? What was it like when he died; how did they react?

Group: Maedhros & Azaghâl
I'm always up for hearing more about these two! Tell me about their alliance. What was their relationship like, what did they think of each other?

Group: Fëanor & Míriel's Handmaidens, Group: Mahtan & Fëanor, Group: Fëanor & Rúmil of Tirion,
Group: Fëanor & Original Followers of Fëanor, Group: Fëanor & Mahtan, Group: Fëanor & Maglor, Group: Fëanor & Maedhros, Group: Fëanor & Curufin, Group: Fëanor & Celegorm, Group: Fëanor & Amrod & Amras,
Group: Fëanor & Celebrimbor

Yes, give me all the Fëanorian content! Tell me about Fëanor's creations, his collaborations, how he raised his children, how he himself grew up, his friends, his teachers, just give me more of my beloved Fëanor. :D

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: The Creation of the Tengwar
  • Worldbuilding: The Creation of the Palantíri
  • Worldbuilding: The Creation of Fëanorian Lamps
  • Worldbuilding: The Creation of the Silmarils
  • Worldbuilding: Fëanor's Lesser Known Works Noldorin Politics and Diplomacy (Silm)
  • Worldbuilding: in-universe history and lore
  • Worldbuilding: Trends and fashion
  • Worldbuilding: Weaving & needlework (Silm)
  • Worldbuilding: Second Age Trade Relations
  • Worldbuilding: Númenor & Lindon
  • Worldbuilding: Elven Politics of the Second Age
  • Worldbuilding: Geopolitics of the Second Age
  • Worldbuilding: Healing/Medicine
  • Worldbuilding: Character Study


The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-earth: non-incest m/m and het requests

Group: Maeglin/Túrin, Group: Maedhros/Turgon
These two pairings caught my eye as being particularly unusual/rare. I'd love any content for them at all! Bonus points for making it work in Beleriand, as opposed to post-rebirth in Valinor/post-end of the world, and not involving a huge canon-divergence (just a minor one).

Group: Fingon/Maedhros
I'd love a look at these two from a diplomatic/geopolitical lens as well as a romantic one, in Beleriand. How do they make their long-distance relationship work? Tell me about gifts they exchanged, how they communicated, meet-ups on the plain of Ard-Galen, battles that turned into romantic rendezvous.

Group: Celebrimbor/Maeglin (Silm)
I'd love a fic where Maeglin sneaks out of Nan Elmoth and finds Celebrimbor (off hunting on the borders of Himlad). They share a night of passion, not realising that they are distantly related, and much, much later, after they are reborn, they get together again, this time for good.

Group: Finrod/Turgon
Finrod and Turgon have dream sex. Finrod dreams about hidden caves, Turgon dreams about hidden towers. They wake up the next morning. It's all very embarrassing.

Group: Glorfindel/Ecthelion
I'd love a look at these two in the very early days of their relationship, perhaps even pre-Gondolin or Beleriand. Did they know each other in childhood in Valinor? In fact, did Glorfindel, a Vanya, follow the Noldor for the sake of Ecthelion?

Group: Círdan/Lalwen
I'm very intrigued by this pairing, especially by how they managed to make it work, considering the delicate balance of diplomatic relations that Círdan's got to tread in Beleriand. I'd love a Lalwen here who is far more useful than ornamental, and pragmatic rather than hot-headed.

Group: Anairë/Fingolfin
I headcanon Anairë as being significantly older than Fingolfin, perhaps even a veteran of the Journey. What does she see in him, how do they work together, and ultimately why do they break apart?

Group: Fëanor/Rúmil of Tirion
I really love the idea of a youthful Fëanor falling for his teacher but also at the same time working on superseding Rúmil's work. And Rúmil can't resist Fëanor, but half the time he's not sure whether to be flattered or insulted....

Group: Eöl/Fëanor (Silm)
I love the thought of these two meeting up in Beleriand, and averting various horrible fates together. Sex in a smithy is a bonus!

Group: Fëanor/Mahtan
Similar to the Rúmil prompt, I'm intrigued by Fëanor getting involved with his mentor while at the same time learning how to be even better than him.

Group: Finwë/Míriel & Fëanor
I'd love to see the few days they had together after Fëanor's birth, and anything that Míriel left as a legacy for Fëanor that he later discovers. (I love the idea of Finwë giving him a letter from his mother.)

Group: Curufin/Curufin's wife
Curufin's wife must have been an interesting person, though her name is lost to history. I speculate that she died either at Alqualondë or shortly thereafter (and so the rumour started that she never left Aman). I'd love to see anything about their relationship, and more about her as a character with a name and a personality.

Group: Fëanor/Nerdanel (Silm)
I'd really love some smutty fic for these two -- it's practically canon that they had an incandescent sex life, at least in the early days. How do they manage a kinky and prolific sex drive with being at the top of their respective professions and increasing numbers of kids?

Group: Elwing/Eärendil
I have a feeling these two were basically childhood sweethearts who are each other's first and only in everything and who got together essentially as soon as (half-)humanly possible. Was it a bit of a scandal that they hooked up so young, from an Elvish perspective?

Group: Galadriel/Celeborn & Celebrían
I'd love to hear about Celebrían's childhood, and what Celeborn and Galadriel were like as parents.

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: Geopolitics of the First Age
  • Worldbuilding: Reception of Same-Sex Relationships
  • Worldbuilding: Diplomacy in Beleriand
  • Worldbuilding: Customs of the Falmari
  • Worldbuilding: Historical Bias
  • Worldbuilding: Art & Literature in First Age
  • Worldbuilding: climate and its impact on society
  • Worldbuilding: Sirion
  • Worldbuilding: Peredhel
  • First Age Infrastructure and Trade
  • Battles of the War of Wrath
  • Worldbuilding: What to Wear in Hithlum
  • Worldbuilding: First Age Aman
  • Worldbuilding: Ice and Darkness


The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-earth: non-incest f/f requests

Group: Anairë/Eärwen
Group: Varda/Ungoliant, Group: Thuringwethil/Varda, Group: Thuringwethil/Meássë
Group: Tar-Míriel/Varda
Group: Lúthien/Nienna
Group: Lúthien/Nellas
Group: Idril/Rían
Group: Idril/Meleth (Nurse of Eärendil)
Group: Elwing/Uinen
Group: Ancalimë/Original Female Character
Group: Erendis/Uinen
Group: Celebrían/Nimrodel
Group: Nellas/Niënor Níniel (Silm)
Group: Niënor Níniel/Finduilas Faelivrin
Group: Gereth/Evranin
group: Aerin/Rían
Group: Aerin/Morwen Eledhwen
My femslash OTP! I would love anything about them, but particularly Aerin trying to help, Morwen trying to be stronger than she needs to be, and finally them figuring out how to trust and care for each other.

Group: Elwing/Original Female Seabird Maia
Group: Amarië/Elenwë

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: Trends and fashion
  • Worldbuilding: Reception of Same-Sex Relationships
  • Worldbuilding: Interspecies Relationships
  • Worldbuilding: Fealty/loyalty (Silm)
  • Worldbuilding: Elven magic & technology
  • Worldbuilding: Telerin Kinslayers
  • Worldbuilding: Psychology of Relationships
  • Worldbuilding: What to Wear in Hithlum
  • Worldbuilding: Cultural differences among elves
  • Worldbuilding: Finduilas is Gil-galad
  • Elves at the End of the World
  • Worldbuilding: Differing Lifespans in Númenor
  • Worldbuilding: Númenorean Culture and Customs


The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-earth: all incest requests

Group: Fëanor/Daurin Tórin
Daurin and Fëanor have sex underneath the Trees ('cause Daurin loves the Trees, and Fëanor loves light, and signals get crossed in a sort of rapturous ecstasy, which they utterly fail to regret afterward?)

Group: Amras/Amrod/Caranthir/Celegorm/Curufin/Fëanor/Maedhros/Maglor
-- Canon-divergence AU! The Fëanorians regain the Silmarils, defeat Morgoth, and rule Beleriand (even Doriath)
-- Two or three of the Fëanorians have sex while others do everyday household tasks like cooking or sewing, before getting drawn into the fun.
-- Secret sex in public, one of them gets horny in a completely inappropriate situation, the rest try to satisfy him without letting anyone other than themselves know.
-- The Sons make a plan to seduce their father and are surprised when it works.

Group: Fëanor/Celegorm


Group: Fëanor/Maglor

Group: Fëanor/Fingolfin


Group: Melian/Lúthien

group: Fëanor/Maedhros

group: Fëanor/Finwe

Group: Aredhel/Fëanor (Silm)
-- Aredhel demanding that Fëanor instruct her in the arts of sex
-- A canon-divergence AU where Fëanor takes Aredhel across with him in the ships and she saves his life
-- Sex in a smithy! Or in Fëanor's workshop.
-- Fëanor adorning her with jewellery, or giving her sex toys as gifts.

Group: Curufin/Maglor
group: Lalaith/Nienor
Group: Erendis/Ancalimë

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: in-universe history and lore
  • Worldbuilding: climate and its impact on society
  • Worldbuilding: Númenor & Lindon
  • Worldbuilding: Trends and fashion
  • Worldbuilding: Reception of Same-Sex Relationships
  • Worldbuilding: Laws and Customs among the Eldar
  • Worldbuilding: Fealty/loyalty (Silm)
  • Worldbuilding: Elven magic & technology
  • Worldbuilding: Art & Literature in First Age
  • Worldbuilding: Fëanor's Lesser Known Works
  • Worldbuilding: Song power
  • Worldbuilding: Noldor architects and builders
  • Noldorin Politics and Diplomacy (Silm)
  • Worldbuilding: Elven Blacksmiths
  • Worldbuilding: Minstrils and Music-Making
  • Festivals in the Years of the Trees
  • Elves at the End of the World


The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-earth: all polyamorous requests

Group: Fingon/Finrod/Maedhros
Group: Maglor's Wife/Curufin's Wife/Caranthir's Wife
Group: Aredhel/Elenwë/Vána
Group: Elwing/Manwë/Varda
Group: Andróg/Beleg Cúthalion/Túrin Turambar (Silm)
Group: Indis/Míriel/Nerdanel
Group: Finwë/Indis/Míriel
group: Anairë/Eärwen/Nerdanel
Group: Finduilas/Nellas/Niënor
Group: Varda/Ilmarë/Iminyë/Tatië/Enelyë
Group: Fingon/Fingon's Wife/Maedhros

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: Laws and Customs among the Eldar
  • Worldbuilding: Interspecies Relationships
  • Worldbuilding: Groups learning/studying each others' languages
  • Worldbuilding: Customs and Rites at Cuiviénen
  • Worldbuilding: The Writing Of History
  • Worldbuilding: building cities and strongholds
  • Worldbuilding: Cultural differences among elves
  • Festivals in the Years of the Trees
  • Worldbuilding: The Roles and Powers of the Ainur in Arda


The Lord of the Rings: gen and single character requests

Arwen Undómiel, Group: Arwen & Frodo
Belladonna Took
Halbarad, Group: Aragorn & Halbarad
Ioreth, Group: Ioreth & Sisters

Group: Aragorn & Bilbo Baggins
Tell me more about this epic friendship! I'm going to assume it started when Aragorn was just ten years old. Did Aragorn ever visit Bag End? Did they travel together at any point?

Group: Gildor Inglorion & Traveling Party, Group: Gildor Inglorion & Bilbo Baggins
I adore Gildor and would love to hear more about him and his companions, especially if Bilbo is involved. Perhaps Gildor and Co visit Bag End? Or meet up with Bilbo somewhere in the hill country? How did they originally meet?

Group: Elrohir & Elladan & Arwen, Group: Elrohir & Elladan & Arwen & Aragorn, Group: Elladan & Elrohir & Dúnedain, Group: Elladan & Elrohir
Just anything involving any of these groups! Tell me about a time Elladan and Elrohir went out orc hunting, or organised an event, or learned something from their sister, or taught something to Aragorn, or patrolled the borders of their lands with the Dúnedain.

Group: Aragorn & Elrond, Group: Aragorn | Thorongil & Ecthelion II, Group: Aragorn & Barliman Butterbur
I always love hearing about anything to do with Aragorn's life, especially the bits we know very little about, like his childhood in Rivendell, his great journeys and errantries, and his life as a Ranger. (I especially love the idea of Barliman driving him up the wall constantly and would love something like Five Times Barliman Butterbur Made Aragorn Frustrated Beyond All Human Endurance and One Time Aragorn Got Subtle Revenge. It doesn't have to be that subtle.)

Group: Elrond & Gandalf
I'd love to hear about the early part of their relationship. When and how did they meet? Was Elrond initially a bit suspicious, due to having met Annatar who also claimed to be an emissary of the Valar?

Group: Elrond & Gilraen
I'd love to see Elrond being a true friend and kind host to Gilraen, and Gilraen's contributions to Rivendell. What are her skills and talents?

Group: Original Character & Original Character
This is the wildcard choice! Pick a couple of worldbuilding tags you like and expand on them using original characters. A couple of librarians in Rivendell? A hobbit in the Shire meeting a Ranger? Healers in Minas Tirith? Some elves in the Wandering Companies?

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: The Wandering Companies
  • Worldbuilding: Production of fabric & clothing
  • Worldbuilding: Life in Rivendell
  • Worldbuilding: Fealty/loyalty (LOTR)
  • Worldbuilding: we're in need of a healer
  • Worldbuilding: Libraries & archives (LotR Books)
  • Worldbuilding: Unwritten Social Rules of Hobbit Society (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: Rangers' Guardianship of the Shire (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: King Elessar's Ban On Men Entering the Shire (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: Hobbitish Politics: A Benevolent Anarchy? (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: Geopolitics of the Third Age (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: children of Elrond with skills inherited from Luthien & Galadriel's foresight
  • Worldbuilding: Aragorn's great journeys & errantries
  • Worldbuilding: Oaths & Mortality (LotR Books)


The Lord of the Rings: all ship requests

Group: Arwen/Aragorn (LOTR Books)
I would love smut for this ship, especially involving an exploration of how Arwen, a half-Elf, differs from other mortal women. I definitely headcanon Arwen as being the dominant one in the relationship, and Aragorn as her worshipful servant, and would love to see her taking gentle control and pushing Aragorn to his limits.

Group: Goldberry/Arwen
As much as I love Aragorn/Arwen, I firmly believe Arwen had a happy and fulfilling life for over 2000 years before he was ever on the scene. I strongly headcanon her as bisexual and would love to see her with Goldberry.

Group: Elrond/Celebrían
I'd love to know more about Celebrían, who she is as a person, and why Elrond loved her for so long without saying anything to her. Presumably she loved him back, so what did she see in him?

Group: Legolas/Gimli (LotR Books)
Legolas/Gimli is something of an OTP for me. I'd love to hear more about their arrival in Valinor: were they expected and welcomed, or did Legolas just turn up one day with his dwarf husband, causing the scandal of the century?

Group: Original Shieldmaiden of Rohan/Original Shieldmaiden of Rohan

Group: Old Man Willow/the Withywindle
This is definitely an intriguing idea for a ship? Are they Goldberry's parents?

group: Berúthiel/Original Female Character(s)
I'd love to see an ultimate happy ending for Berúthiel (and her cats!) *resists urge to make pussy joke*

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: The Choice of the Peredhel
  • Worldbuilding: Roads & Trade in the Reunited Kingdom (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: King Elessar's Ban On Men Entering the Shire (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: Geopolitics of the Third Age (LOTR books)
  • Worldbuilding: Gondor after the War of the Ring
  • Worldbuilding: children of Elrond with skills inherited from Luthien & Galadriel's foresight
  • Worldbuilding: Elf/dwarf relationships (LotR books)
  • Worldbuilding: Trade & diplomacy in the early Fourth Age
  • Worldbuilding: Fate of the Three Rings after the One is destroyed
  • Worldbuilding: Motivations of Sentient Trees
  • Worldbuilding: Nature Spirits of Middle-earth
  • Worldbuilding: Rebuilding Minas Tirith


Leaf by Niggle

Niggle, Parish, First Voice, Second Voice, Parish's Wife
I'm very interested in how this world works, if you take it out of the realm of allegory. I'd love to hear more about the First Voice and Second Voice, the reason for the Journey, and what's going on with the Workhouse. And of course, it would be great to hear more about Niggle's Parish. Don't feel you have to use all these characters in your fic -- it would be, in fact, super intriguing to follow an original character on their journey to Niggle's Parish.

Worldbuilding Tags:
  • Worldbuilding: The Workhouse
  • Worldbuilding: The Town Council
  • Worldbuilding: The Journey
  • Worldbuilding: Niggle's Parish


Smith of Wootton Major

Alf Prentice, Rob Rider, Group: Nell/Queen of Faery
I'd love to hear more about Alf and why he wound up making cakes in Wootton Major for years, instead of being off in Faery kinging.

And I would absolutely love the Queen of Faery having her own adventures in the mortal world, especially if they involved Nell.

Crossovers

Group: Nell (Smith of Wootton Major)/Nellas (Silmarillion)

Group: Finduilas as Gil-galad (Silm)/Celebrían (LotR)/Elrond (LotR)
I love this threesome with Gil-galad being male, but make Gil-galad Finduilas, and wow, I'm super, super into it. I'd love to hear about all the layers of secrecy involved and the intimacy the three of them end up wound together in, to make a relationship between them possible.

Group: Finduilas as Gil-galad (Silm)/Celebrían (LotR)
"Make new friends and keep the old; one is silver, the other gold."

Group: Fëanor (Silm) & Gandalf (LOTR)
We know Gandalf is a Fëanor fanboy as late as the Third Age, but what if they actually talked back in the Years of the Trees? I love the idea of Fëanor being the first one to say "He who breaks a thing to find out what it is has left the path of wisdom" and would be totally over the moon to see Fëanor and Olórin have a conversation, perhaps as Fëanor works on the Palantíri?

Group: Gildor (LotR)/Maglor (Silm)
I'd love some smut for these two! I really love the idea of Gildor being a kinky little thing, the kind of person who would lube himself up before going out to meet his lover or who would hide under a table and distract his musician boyfriend with a sneaky blow job or who would crawl into his lover's bed in the middle of the night. There's also the potential for post-battle victory sex or just some fun sex pollen, sexy bondage, or Maglor being the gentlest, tenderest of doms for Gildor.

Group: Goldberry (LotR Books)/Celebrían (Silm)
Group: Arwen Undómiel (LOTR Movies)/Tauriel (Hobbit Movies)
Celegorm (Silm ) & Paksu & Valkotukka (Father Christmas Letters)
Celegorm (Silmarillion) & Cave Bear (Father Christmas Letters)
Celegorm (Silm) & Great Bear (Father Christmas Letters)